Backpacks

Road Tests :: Heimplanet Daypack

by , September 12, 2013

What’s it about?

Picture a Goruck GR1 that can tip over and double as a work satchel.

Heimplanet is an innovative tent company making a move into carry. They’ve designed a quiver of bags that all draw from a similar design palette.

The smallest bag in the Heimplanet Monolith series is this Daypack, which is undoubtedly inspired by the classic form and tactical vibe of Goruck packs. However it adds features, most notable of which is that it lets you spin the bag and add a shoulder strap for satchel carry. It also changes up the fabric, adds some front straps, and tweaks a few details to make it their own.

Who it suits

The sweet spot of this bag is for the folk that travel a bit with work. You can fit all your work toys with a change of clothes, and yet present well in front of a client. When you’re done with your meetings, you can swing it around as a backpack and cover serious airport miles without doing your back in.

Who it doesn’t suit

This is a reasonably versatile bag, but it’s more about carrying work, travel and study tools than getting active, so don’t try and run marathons with it. And it’s well enough made, but it’s not going to handle the abuse that a Goruck can withstand, so don’t try and dodge bullets with it either.

Design

Looks

It’s black and rectangular – that’s the conservative bit. It then adds some tactical vibe with MOLLE webbing and some accessory pouch options. They include colored zip pulls if you want to spice it up a little, and a printed internal lining is standard.

All up, it’s a reasonably attractive pack only let down by the genericness of high denier nylon (which some folk still love).

Materials

In our eyes, the single easiest way to improve this bag would be changing up the fabric. The Daypack runs with 840D nylon fabric (with a small panel of 1680D), all with what feels like a PU x2 backing. For the intended audience, this bag would probably work better in a coated canvas or a heathered polyester. I say that for two reasons…

a) High denier nylon is kinda 2003.

b) This high denier nylon is lacking structure.

The 840D has a loose weave, which means it lacks the structure that would keep the bag open and up where you need it. With only a very light PU backing, the backing is not really helping here.

The plus to this fabric? It looks ‘travel’, it holds up pretty well to abrasion, and the soft drape means this pack sits quite well when empty.

Construction

Generally solid, although the stitching isn’t locked off super tight, so you get a few thread-ends saying hi after harder wear. They didn’t unravel further, so a quick lick with a flame fixes them, but it could be tighter.

Hardware

The titanium G-hooks are a nice touch, which keeps weight down, durability high, and adds some handy options (like slinging a jacket on the front panel).

There’s not much plastic to break, or hard bits to clang or weigh you down, so the whole bag feels quite light and neat.

Features

Transformer action

More backpacks should offer a swap to landscape. No matter what backpack you choose, it’s going to struggle to look appropriate with a suit. Simply swapping the bag to a horizontal shoulder carry radically improves your ability to look sharp when you need to.

The transforming between backpack and shoulder bag works okay enough with the Heimplanet. You unhook the straps, push them behind the back panel, and close a zip. You then slip the shoulder strap G-hooks through some loops and you’re ready. It doesn’t have the elegance of the Qwstion approach, but each final stage is well resolved.

The shoulder strap doesn’t have a perfect home, but I found keeping it behind the back panel worked well enough.

It just misses a couple of those next level tricks for making the most of the transforming concept. For instance, I’d love to see a smart place for the shoulder strap to live when in backpack mode. Heck, I’d love to see the shoulder strap double as a great waist belt (which could be tucked away) when in backpack mode. Perhaps they’ll get that for next revision…

It doesn’t actually do this with the waist belt, but it should…

Pouches

The optional pouches are not quite resolved for my liking. They are a little heavy and overly structured. They’re a touch fiddly to attach. But mostly they look a little odd stuck on the front or side of the pack. They just don’t integrate into the silhouette as well as some others do.

I also found myself wishing that the pouches could attach to the inside of the pack for when I wanted to clean up the silhouette, but they don’t have a home within the internals (short of being shoved inside).

It doesn’t actually do this, but it should…

Performance

Comfort

It’s quite a comfortable pack for travel and business needs. The laptop sits against your back, so you can’t arch nicely while riding, but it’s fine for standard duty.

There’s a wonderful lack of airmesh (yay for scratch-free), and the straps are well padded.

Space & Access

There is no doubt that this bag has been designed with work travel in mind. Your laptop slips out easily even when the bag is full. There are some nice internal pockets for organising toiletries or work bits. And the size and shape easily accommodate airplane storage restrictions.

The side access zip is great for getting to your laptop when moving through security or setting up for your day’s work. A 15″ laptop is the largest it will fit, and this takes a touch of alignment to get in, but it works smoothly enough.

Unfortunately the internal pockets work better in vertical backpack mode than horizontal satchel mode, but that’s only a small thing, and you can get at them well enough.

The tuck-away front straps are a nice way to haul an oversize jacket or random purchase, and the low profile G-hooks mean you don’t feel them when tucked away.

Weatherability

It’s fine for a light shower, with a water-resistant zipper covering the laptop zip, and good storm flaps over the main zipper. It’s certainly not for torrential downpours though.

Value

The Daypack is €170 (~US$230), plus around €30 per pouch. That means it’s slipping under the $295 of a Goruck GR1 (or $275 for the sexy new SK26), but not yet cheap on a global scale.

Does that represent value? For me, the fabric and construction quality need to be nailed before that’s good value. The rest of the components are dialled for that price.

Other bags to check

The Goruck range needs to be on your radar. The GR1 is the most obvious comparison. You’ll miss out on the shoulder bag conversion, but you’ll get nicer fabric and more bomber construction.

The Qwstion Daypack pulls a similar transformer trick, but with a slightly more fashion sensibility.

Thule has a similar design vibe and fabric choices, but at a cheaper price.

And then for a little more design flare, Cote&Ciel are totally rocking my boat at the moment.

Verdict

This is a great format for a work and travel bag. It can pass between work and play functions smoothly, looking good in most environments. The rectangular silhouette fits work gear well, and the size suits short work trips nicely.

It does though feel like the first release for a brand. There is not yet enough magic and insight brought to the piece, missing a few of the really nice opportunities to leave a mark with your emotions. I’d love to see a nicer fabric offered, some better consideration to the poetry of transformation, and a little more care taken in the construction and stitch work.

Having said all that, the Heimplanet Daypack is already a very useful bag that shows we should expect some nice things from this brand going forwards.

PS: Check out these guys’ tents. They’re the shelter of choice for Red Bull nutters around the globe.

-

  • Eamon

    Transforming a backpack to a vertical shoulder bag might be a more simpler option than transforming it a “landscape” mode. At least for vertical, there no need to change the way internally the bag plan to hold the stuff inside.

    • AA

      I’d say you risk a very heavy bag that way. I suspect you get better weight distribution if the bag is horizontal.

  • http://www.fromhighabove.com JC Canfield

    Great point Eamon, That is an underutilized method of converting a pack. Often, I think because it can look terrible.

    I like the patterned/ lined inside. And ti hardware?! Want.

  • Pingback: Week In Review ~ 14 September | Carryology

  • AA

    Been waiting for a review on this for a long time. It’s actually, for once, “cheap” for me as I live in the EU. I’m glad I’m not the only one who can see the GR1 influence. I felt like it was like a mix between the TAD Litespeed and the GR1.

    But I just find the fabric so…meh. The lack of internal pockets are an issue too. The attached pouches look meh as well and I’m disappointed the shoulder strap can’t pull double duty.

    They really should have curved the pockets more to make them useable in either mode. Probably going for a topo designs briefcase instead.

    • Dennis Huang

      Lack of internal pockets – do you mean it doesn’t have internal organizers for pens, business cards, etc? Does it have a key laynard?

      • AA

        Hate pen/business card holders. Like pockets big enough to hold something sizeable. This is the killer feature of the Goruck series for me and why I own so many.

  • Dave

    I bought the bag but it is going back. I received a bum unit — had some kind of stain (probably glue) on the front zipper assembly. Shouldn’t have made it past QC. The bag is nice, but I don’t like it enough to reorder. The conversion feature is cool but gimmicky. The front zippers aren’t robust enough; as a result they catch the trim. The material is ok but nothing special; it is definitely not the ballistic they promoted. I compared next to a GR1, which feels much better made, is a tad bigger (which for me is a plus) and is more comfortable to carry. The straps on the Heimplanet bag do not seem robust; the mesh lining on the inside strap is somewhat loose and flimsy — i don’t have a lot of confidence it will survive long-term use. and finally the Heimplanet looks too much like a GR1 – feels like an inferior copy.

    • http://www.carryology.com/ ando

      Dave, thanks for sharing that stuff.

      In the hope of improving my reviews, can I ask if most of those issues caught you by surprise?

      I generally only use ‘less than glowing’ language to point out an issue, rather than directly panning it. Were you already expecting to be underwhelmed by the fabric and the construction and the resemblance to a GR1? Or was I not obvious enough about that stuff in the review?

      We really want this stuff to be helpful, so if you can let me know, we should be able to improve our reviews going forwards.

      And thanks again – feedback is key to getting better.

      • Dave

        Not really… no issues with your review… I thought it was helpful and liked that you were thoughtful and measured… For me, I thought I liked 840D nylon (based on other stuff I have) but when I put it side by side with the GR1 in cordura it just didn’t compare (though I wish cordura was smoother and less prone to picking up stray lint).

        My grail is still high quality ballistic (the stuff Tom Bihn uses or even Tumi) but there just aren’t enough options out there. If Heimplanet used all 1680, as well as beefier main zippers, I’d reconsider.
        I liked the weather resistant accessory zippers on the Heimplanet, but the main zipper caught when I tested the bag and that annoyed me.

        You were spot on in your closing “It does though feel like the first release for a brand. There is not yet enough magic and insight brought to the piece, missing a few of the really nice opportunities to leave a mark with your emotions. I’d love to see a nicer fabric offered, some better consideration to the poetry of transformation, and a little more care taken in the construction and stitch work.”

        Keep up the great work on the site. I’m a big fan, with the only downside is that I am going to accumulate more bags than I know what to do with…

        • http://www.carryology.com/ ando

          Thanks Dave. Great to hear.

          And yep, carry accumulation is a curse most of us suffer. You know it’s bad when you start planning your whole office around bag shelving!

  • Dennis Huang

    Does this bag have internal organizers for pens, business cards, etc? Does it have a key laynard?

Carryology delivered

Your inbox. every two weeks. Only the best stuff, we promise.